Navigating the legal landscape of hybrid work policies in the UK, Ireland, France, and the DACH region

As the world evolves, so does the future of work. One significant trend shaping this evolution is hybrid work policies. These policies blend remote and office-based work. They are reshaping how you interact with your job and colleagues. So, let's explore how the UK, France, and the DACH region approach these changes. This comparison will help you understand the varied landscapes of these policies.

‍

The hybrid work framework

Having a hybrid work schedule is great for many people. Why? You spend some days at the office while enjoying the quiet of your home on other days. This kind of schedule has become popular recently due to more than one benefit – it increases productivity and makes offices less crowded. In turn, people, especially introverts, report feeling happier than ever while working. The diminished commuting time daily can also add up to this good feeling. This balance allows the best of both worlds: a calm retreat or an energetic setting each day of the week.

However, implementing a hybrid work model requires more than logistical adjustments — it involves navigating complex legal requirements that differ from country to country. Understanding these differences is crucial for multinational companies implementing unified yet compliant hybrid work strategies across borders.

United Kingdom: a flexible yet regulated approach

According to CIPD, 78% of companies in the UK allow hybrid working. This is not only to please the workforce – it is a strategically well-played move. Companies find flexible working arrangements can significantly reduce overhead costs while maintaining productivity. Big companies like Barclays and HSBC are excellent examples. They have implemented hybrid models that allow employees to split their time between home and office.

In the UK, hybrid work is primarily governed by existing employment laws, with specific guidance emerging from the Flexible Working Regulations 2014. Under these regulations:

• All employees can request flexible working arrangements, including hybrid work, after 26 weeks of continuous service. 
• Employers must consider such requests "reasonably," but they can reject them for specific business reasons, such as the inability to reorganize work among existing staff or the impact on quality and performance.

Moreover, UK law mandates that any changes to working arrangements must be formally agreed upon, potentially requiring amendments to employment contracts. This is particularly relevant for hybrid work models, where employees may split their time between home and office. Health and safety regulations apply (such as the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974), meaning employers must ensure that home workspaces meet safety standards. This requirement can complicate hybrid work arrangements, primarily when employees work from various locations.

‍

Ireland: emphasizing employee rights

Ireland's approach to hybrid work is similar to that of the UK but strongly emphasizes employee rights. The forthcoming Right to Request Remote Work Bill will formalize employees' rights to request remote or hybrid work arrangements. 

Employers will be legally obliged to respond to such requests within a specified timeframe, and the refusal of a request must be based on clear and justifiable reasons. This bill aims to create a balanced framework that supports the needs of both employers and employees in a hybrid work environment.

Irish law also significantly emphasizes health and safety obligations for remote workers. The Safety, Health, and Welfare at Work Act 2005 mandates that employers conduct risk assessments of home workspaces and ensure that employees have the necessary equipment to work safely and effectively from home. This includes ergonomic furniture and IT equipment, ensuring employees' well-being is protected, regardless of their work location.

France: a structured framework with a focus on equality

France has a well-defined legal framework for telework, which extends to hybrid work arrangements. French companies must strictly respect the regulations that protect workers' hours and health, even when they work from home. These laws ensure that any hybrid work model functions according to national standards, including workplace safety and employee wellbeing. For instance, a law passed in 2017 states that companies with over 50 employees negotiate specific terms about remote work rights. This move shows how deeply ingrained worker protections are in the French approach to these policies.

French labor law, mainly through Article L1222-9 of the French Labour Code, requires a formal agreement between the employer and employee for remote work. This agreement typically outlines the conditions under which remote work will occur, including work hours, the provision of equipment, and compensation for work-related expenses. These agreements ensure that both parties understand their rights and obligations in a hybrid work model.

One distinctive aspect of French law is its focus on ensuring equality between remote and office-based workers. Employers must provide the same benefits to remote workers as those available to their office-based counterparts, including access to training and career development opportunities. Additionally, France's right to disconnect law, which allows employees to ignore work-related communications outside of working hours, applies to hybrid workers, helping to maintain work-life balance. This legal framework promotes fairness and helps prevent burnout by ensuring hybrid workers have clear boundaries between work and personal time.

‍

DACH Region: balancing flexibility with tradition

In the DACH region, hybrid work is supported by a combination of legal guidelines and cultural attitudes, with the emphasis on precision and efficiency, as expected.

In Germany, companies are proactively rethinking offices to enhance hybrid work setups. For example, Siemens launched a 'mobile working' policy allowing employees to work from anywhere for two to three days a week, reflecting a trust-based work culture. This way, their employees can even take a “vacation” while technically still working. Here, the policies have taken a somewhat different path. Here, the emphasis is on precision and efficiency, as expected.

However, no specific legislation directly governs hybrid work in Germany, Austria, or Switzerland. Instead, the region relies on broader employment laws and collective agreements. For instance, in Germany, while hybrid work is permitted, any changes to an employee's work location or schedule must be mutually agreed upon, typically requiring an amendment to the employment contract. The German Civil Code (BGB) covers these aspects, protecting employer and employee rights.

Austria follows a similar approach, with specific laws governing telework. These laws, such as those found in the Austrian Employment Contract Law Adaptation Act (AVRAG), require employers to provide necessary resources for remote work and ensure that employees' rights and protections are consistent regardless of where they work. 

In Switzerland, the focus is on maintaining employee health and safety. Employers must provide suitable working conditions for hybrid workers and ensure that working hours comply with legal limits outlined in the Swiss Code of Obligations.

Culturally, the DACH region has been slower in adopting hybrid work than other parts of Europe, partly due to a traditional preference for in-person work environments. However, the pandemic has accelerated the adoption of hybrid models, with many organizations now recognizing the benefits of flexibility in attracting and retaining talent. This cultural shift and supportive legal frameworks have paved the way for hybrid work to become more widespread in the region.

Adapting to hybrid work abroad

As an employee, moving from the US to the UK, France, or the DACH region involves significant professional and personal adjustments. If you're planning a move to Austria, for example, you'll find a work environment that values work-life balance and precision, as expected. This will differ from what you might be used to back in the American work culture. Similarly, the way they do hybrid work in France, with its strict labor laws, or the UK, which might offer more flexibility, will be a change.

To adapt to these new work culture norms, you must stay open and flexible, understand local labor laws, and learn about workplace norms and expectations. It's also essential to manage your logistics efficiently. Secure the right visa, research local tax implications, and set up banking and healthcare essentials.

To ensure a smooth relocation from point A to point B, consider hiring international movers specializing in expatriate relocations. These professionals can help navigate the complexities of international moving, from packing and shipping your belongings to handling customs regulations. They can also offer valuable advice on settling into your new home, giving you time to research and prepare for the changes that will come your way. 

Tailoring hybrid work policies to regional requirements

Navigating the legal landscape of hybrid work requires a comprehensive understanding of each region's regulatory frameworks and cultural contexts. While the UK and Ireland offer robust protections for employee rights, France emphasizes equality and the right to disconnect. The DACH region, on the other hand, balances legal obligations with a strong cultural preference for traditional work environments. It's crucial to grasp these regional differences to tailor hybrid work policies effectively.

For businesses operating across these regions, it's crucial to tailor hybrid work policies to comply with local laws while also considering cultural attitudes towards work. By doing so, organizations can create flexible, compliant, and effective hybrid work models that meet the business's and its employees' needs.

If you are looking for some help tailoring and managing your hybrid work policies, book a free demo session with one of our workplace experts and learn how deskbird can boost office engagement and support your hybrid work strategies.

‍